Taxation on Silver Investments in ETFs vs Mutual Funds

With the recent growth in silver, Silver ETFs and Mutual Funds have emerged as an attractive option for investment in the precious metal. Taxation on silver ETFs and mutual funds is based on the holding period of such assets.

Key Highlights

• STCG on Silver ETFs held upto 12 months will be taxed at applicable slab rates. Whereas, LTCG on Silver ETFs held for more than 12 months will be taxed at 12.5% without indexation. 
• STCG on Silver Mutual Fund help upto 24 months are taxed as per applicable slab rates and LTCG on Silver Mutual Funds held for more than 24 months are taxed at 12.5% without indexation. 

What are Silver ETFs?

Silver ETFs are investment funds that track the price of silver. These are traded on the stock exchanges like regular shares and provide investors with an option to invest in silver without having to physically own the metal. Silver ETFs invest in physical silver or other silver related assets. 

What are Silver Mutual Funds?

Silver mutual funds primarily invest their pooled money in units of silver ETFs or other silver related assets. Key differences between silver ETFs and mutual funds is that ETFs track an underlying index or asset, whereas mutual funds are actively managed investment funds.

Taxation on Silver ETFs

• Short-term capital gains (STCG) from silver ETFs held for up to 12 months are taxed as per the applicable slab rates of the taxpayers. 
• However, tax on silver ETFs as a result of long-term capital gains (LTCG) by holding ETFs for more than 12 months are taxed at 12.5% without indexation. 

Taxation on Silver Mutual Funds

• Taxation on silver mutual funds gains are similar with STCG taxed at applicable tax slab rates and LTCG taxed at 12.5% without indexation. 
• However, in case of mutual funds, funds held for up to 24 months are classified as short term and those held for more than 24 months are classified as long term. 

Silver ETFs and Silver Mutual Funds Key Differences 

• Silver ETFs offer more liquidity compared to mutual funds as they are traded on the stock exchange and can be bought and sold easily. 
• Taxation on silver ETFs and Silver Mutual Funds is the same with short-term gains taxed at applicable slabs rates of the taxpayers and long-term gains taxed at 12.5% without indexation. 
• Silver ETFs held for up to 12 months will be classified as short-term capital gains, whereas silver ETFs held for more than 12 months will be classified as long-term capital gains. 
• Silver mutual funds held for more than 24 months will be LTCG and silver mutual funds held for up to 24 months will be STCG. 

Tax Planning Strategies for Silver Investments

Understanding taxation on Silver ETFs and Mutual Funds is essential for investors to be able to save tax on their respective gains. Taxpayers can save tax on silver ETFs and mutual funds gains through the following ways:

• Investors can save tax by holding ETFs and Mutual Funds for long-term, as it provides lower tax rates. 
• ETFs provide more liquidity with lower cost comparative to mutual funds which have expense ratios, exit load and stamp duty. 
• Taxpayers falling in the lower tax slabs can focus on short-term investments.
• Tax loss harvesting also helps taxpayers to set-off losses and minimise capital gains. 

The key to tax planning is to understand the implications on STCG and LTCG and other costs that may be involved in ETFs and Mutual Funds. 

Silver ETFs vs Mutual Funds: Which is Better?

To determine the better investment option between Silver ETFs and Mutual Funds, it is essential to understand the pros and cons of the same. 

Conclusion

Silver ETFs and Silver Mutual Funds offer investors with different options and benefits to invest in silver. However, it is important to understand the cost involved and the tax implications in order to make proper investment decisions.

Related Articles:
1. Tax on Gold ETFs vs Gold Mutual Funds
2. ETFs vs Mutual Funds - Which is Better for Long Term?
3. Income Tax on Silver Utensils: Taxation, Capital Gains & Saving Strategies