Optimising Credits in the New Rules for Input Tax Credit Utilisation

Just when we were settling with the existing return related procedures, the government changed the procedure for the order of set-off of the same with effect from 29 March 2019. However, the functionality of the portal continued to be the old mechanism.

The new rules were laid down to reduce the balance lying under IGST Credits to optimise the distribution between the Center and the state. However, if the mechanism is not understood and off-set is not optimised, then the businesses might end up on higher working capital requirements. Thus, it becomes imperative to understand what is the change and how it will impact businesses.

 

The New Law on Order of ITC Set-Off

 

CGST Circular No. 98/17/2019 was issued on 23 April 2019 has clarified the order of ITC utilisation for each tax head. It further stated that until the new Rule 88A of the CGST Rules is implemented on the GST portal, taxpayers have to follow the facility available on the GST portal. Such facility was made available from July 2019 returns onwards.

Firstly, let’s take a look at the two new sections inserted in the CGST Act-

“49A. Notwithstanding anything contained in section 49, the input tax credit on account of central tax, State tax or Union territory tax shall be utilised towards payment of integrated tax, central tax, State tax or Union territory tax, as the case may be, only after the input tax credit available on account of integrated tax has first been utilised fully towards such payment.

49B. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Chapter and subject to the provisions of clause (e) and clause (f) of sub-section (5) of section 49, the Government may, on the recommendations of the Council, prescribe the order and manner of utilisation of the input tax credit on account of integrated tax, central tax, State tax or Union territory tax, as the case may be, towards payment of any such tax.”.
 
Subsequently, the rule 88A has been inserted to notify the above new provision via CT notification no. 16/2019 dated 29th March 2019.

Rule 88A. Order of utilization of input tax credit.- Input tax credit on account of integrated tax shall first be utilised towards payment of integrated tax, and the amount remaining, if any, may be utilised towards the payment of central tax and State tax or Union territory tax, as the case may be, in any order:
Provided that the input tax credit on account of central tax, State tax or Union territory tax shall be utilised towards payment of integrated tax, central tax, State tax or Union territory tax, as the case may be, only after the input tax credit available on account of integrated tax has first been utilised fully.
 
As per the Circular No: 98/17/2019 dated 23 April 2019, it has been clarified that-

As per the provisions of Section 49 of the CGST Act, credit of integrated tax has to be utilised first for payment of integrated tax, then Central tax and then State tax, in that order mandatorily. This led to a situation, in certain cases, where a taxpayer has to discharge his tax liability on account of one type of tax (say State tax) through electronic cash ledger, while the input tax credit on account of other types of tax (say Central tax) remains unutilised in electronic credit ledger.

The newly inserted rule 88A in the CGST Rules allows utilisation of input tax credit of integrated tax towards the payment of Central tax and State tax, or as the case may be, Union Territory tax, in any order subject to the condition that the entire input tax credit on account of integrated tax is completely exhausted first before the input tax credit on account of Central tax or State/Union Territory tax can be utilised.

It is clarified that after the insertion of the said rule, the order of utilisation of input tax credit will be as per the order (of numerals) given below:

Input tax credit on account of	Output liability on account of Integrated tax	Output liability on account of Central tax	Output liability on account of State tax
Integrated tax	(I)	(II) – In any order in any proportion
(III) Input tax credit on account of Integrated tax to be completely exhausted mandatorily
Central tax	(V)	(IV)	Not permitted
State tax/Union Territory tax	(VII)	Not permitted	(VI)

 

With the new rules in place, it is mandatory to utilise the entire IGST available in electronic credit ledger before utilising ITC on CGST or SGST. The order of setting off ITC of IGST can be done in any proportion and any order towards setting off the CGST or SGST output after utilising the same for IGST output.
 

Comparison Between Old and New Law on GST Set-Off

 

The table below highlights the differences in the order of ITC utilisation between the old system and the new system-
As per the old set-off rules, the following is the order and priority for ITC utilisation–

Liability of →	IGST	CGST	SGST
ITC of↓
IGST	1	2	3
CGST	2	1	Not permitted
SGST	2	Not permitted	1

 
From July 2019 onwards the below mode of off-set functionality has been made available, the following is the order and priority for ITC utilisation

Liability of →	IGST	CGST	SGST
ITC of↓
IGST	1	2*
CGST	4	3	Not permitted
SGST	6	Not permitted	5

 

*The order of utilisation of IGST credit post offset to IGST liability can be in any order or proportion between CGST/SGST but the only pre-condition is exhausting IGST completely before using other credits.
Hence, from the above table for new rules, it can be concluded that any taxpayer must begin with set-off process starting with ITC of IGST and utilise it completely before proceeding to utilise the ITC of CGST or ITC of SGST.

 

Illustrations on How GST Set-Off Works

Let us discuss the applicability of provisions using two illustrations.

Illustration I: To understand the order of IGST credit set-off

There is an only procedural change in utilising IGST credit. To understand the set-off from a practical perspective, let us take an example. Suppose, Mr X has the following GST liabilities and GST inputs.

(all figures in INR)

Type of GST	Output Liability	Input Tax Credit
IGST	500	2000
CGST	1000	150
SGST/ UTGST	1000	150
Total	2500	2300

As per the existing system, the set-off takes place as follows-

(all figures in INR)

Type of Tax	Liability	Credit Available	Set-off of Liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	2,000	500  (from IGST)	_	_
CGST	1,000	150	150 (from CGST) 850 (from IGST)	–	–
SGST/ UTGST	1,000	150	150 (from SGST) 650 (from IGST)	200	–

 
You can see that CGST or SGST payable needs to be paid first with CGST credit or SGST credit respectively.

 

However, as per the new procedure of set-off, the IGST credit available will need to be set-off and the following are the three possible ways in which this can be done-

 
Scenario 1: Set off of unutilised IGST credit completely towards CGST

(all figures in INR)

Type of Tax	Liability	Credit Available	Set-off of Liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	2,000	500  (from IGST)	_	_
CGST	1,000	150	1000* (from IGST)	–	150
SGST/ UTGST	1,000	150	500 (from IGST) 150 (from SGST)	350	–

 
Scenario 2: Set off of unutilised IGST credit completely towards SGST

(all figures in INR)

Type of Tax	Liability	Credit Available	Set-off of Liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	2,000	500  (from IGST)	_	_
CGST	1,000	150	500 (from IGST) 150 (from CGST)	350	_
SGST/ UTGST	1,000	150	1000* (from IGST)	–	150

 
Scenario 3: Set-off of unutilised IGST credit partly towards CGST & SGST liability in an equal proportion

(all figures in INR)

Type of Tax	Liability	Credit Available	Set-off of Liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	2,000	500  (from IGST)	_	_
CGST	1,000	150	750* (from IGST) 150 (from CGST)	100	_
SGST/ UTGST	1,000	150	750* (from IGST) 150 (From SGST)	100	_

 
*Note:In this illustration, we came up with only three scenarios, whereas the law does not place any strict rule of attributing entire unutilised IGST credit to CGST or SGST liability. A taxpayer can utilise IGST credit in any proportion and in any order, but the condition is to completely utilise the IGST credit before using CGST or SGST credit.

So as you can see in the example, IGST credit has been utilised first as per the new system of set-off, only after which, can CGST or SGST/UTGST be set-off.
To optimise credit utilisation it is advisable to follow Scenario 3.

Illustration II: To understand business Impact due to the new rule
From the illustration 1, we can observe that the overall GST output liability was higher than the overall GST input and now we are going to see a case where overall GST input is higher than the overall GST output.

Suppose, Mr X has the following liability and input credit for a tax period as follows-

(all figures in INR)

Type of GST	Output Liability	Input Tax Credit
IGST	500	1,000
CGST	500	300
SGST/ UTGST	500	300
Total	1500	1600

 

Let us see how the ITC of IGST can be utilised in different ways from the following three scenarios:

Scenario 1: Set off of unutilised IGST credit completely towards CGST

(all figures in INR)

Type of GST	Liability	Credit available	Set-off of liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	1,000	500 (From IGST)	–	–
CGST	500	300	500* (From IGST)	–	300
SGST/ UTGST	500	300	300 (From SGST/ UTGST)	200	–

 

Scenario 2: Set off of unutilised IGST credit completely towards SGST

(all figures in INR)

Type of GST	Liability	Credit available	Set-off of liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	1,000	500 (From IGST)	–	–
CGST	500	300	300 (From CGST)	200	–
SGST/ UTGST	500	300	500* (From IGST)	–	300

 

Scenario 3: Set-off of unutilised IGST credit partly towards CGST & SGST liability in an equal proportion

(all figures in INR)

Type of GST	Liability	Credit available	Set-off of liability	Balance to be paid in cash	Balance credit available
IGST	500	1,000	500 (From IGST)	–	–
CGST	500	300	250* (From IGST) 250 (From CGST)	–	50
SGST/ UTGST	500	300	250* (From IGST) 250 (From SGST)	–	50

 
*Note: In this illustration, we came up with only three scenarios whereas the law does not place any strict rule of attributing entire unutilised IGST credit wholly to either CGST or SGST liability. A taxpayer can utilise IGST credit in any proportion and in any order, but the condition is to completely utilise the IGST credit before using CGST or SGST credit.
In the first two scenarios, the taxpayer has to pay either CGST or SGST and either there is a balance of CGST credit or SGST credit lying in Electronic Credit Ledger (ECL) respectively. But if the taxpayer follows scenario 3, there is no need for a cash payment of either CGST or SGST liability and he can also carry forward an equal amount of CGST and SGST in ECL so that in succeeding months if the purchase or sales pattern changes from inter-state to intra-state or vice-versa, retaining an equal balance in both the ledgers will help optimising the utilisation of credits in future as well. This measure has to be carefully monitored.

Updates on GST Portal

The validations based on the changes in the rule has been updated on the portal from July 2019 onwards.
 

Impact on Business

Let us discuss how exactly does this impact your business-

The new GST offset rules mandates for complete utilisation of IGST input credit before using the CGST or SGST input credit.

In illustration 2 we can observe that the taxpayer has a higher credit due to interstate purchases when compared to the intrastate purchase. In turn, the sales are more within the state when compared to outside the state. It leads to the accumulation of more IGST input credit. Accordingly, if this is not properly utilised it may lead to blockage of working capital.

If the taxpayer follows either of the scenario 1 or 2 in the illustration II, they are evidently deferring the respective CGST or SGST credits balance (as the case may be) to be utilised over several tax periods. It results in blockage of working capital for a considerable period of time. Alternatively, the taxpayer should wait for a future day where his interstate sales (IGST liability) are higher than intrastate sales to completely utilise the balance credit of CGST or SGST brought forward. If the taxpayer goes with scenario 3 by utilising available credit in equal proportion of CGST and SGST, he can avoid the payment of tax and the blockage of working capital that can follow.

However, from the government’s point of view, the new provision is an immediate measure to allow smooth distribution of IGST revenue.

Takeaway:

The GST portal allows taxpayers to manually set off the input tax credit against the output liabilities. It is advisable that the taxpayers make optimum utilisation of ITC available to them by careful allocation of credits every tax period. The new off-set mechanism in no way leads to additional working capital requirements compared to the old mechanism if properly optimised.

Further in case of carrying forward credits it is very much advisable to strike a balance & retain equal credits in both CGST and SGST/UTGST ledgers for optimising credits in future as well. The easiest way to accomplish this is after using the IGST credits for the IGST liability, the balance available in IGST credits to be equally utilised for CGST/SGST credits.

If businesses have missed out doing it in the last two months in the next month they can optimise on it to arrive at an equal balance in both CGST/SGST credit ledgers in case of excess ITC availability and continue the same henceforth.